NOT SO SILENT NIGHT TICKETS ON-SALE NOW: 12/15 @ South Side Ballroom featuring Fall Out Boy, James Bay, And George Ezra

Who’s Cake is the Best?

cakes1 Who’s Cake is the Best?

Vote and decide and leave a comment.

  • Veronica

    Ok Leigh Ann this one looks like you took a pic from a website cake decor…No cheating allowed!! lol

    • Diana

      Leigh Ann…..really???

  • Leslie

    Leigh Ann, didn’t we see this on Cake Boss a few weeks ago??

  • carol

    Let’s get real… way the other is a homemade cake.
    I go for the 13×9 cake.


    Did Leign Ann ACTUALLY bake & decorate that cake????

  • Rebecca

    I had to vote for Julie’s cake because they did not put up a picture of a cake THAT LEIGH ANN MADE!!!!

  • kat

    Leigh Ann your cake looks beautiful, but it’s not home made… Julie looks home made..

  • Bev Owen

    Sorry Leigh, but this does not look like one that was homemade.

  • D.J. Zeller

    I’m sure Julie’s tastes better. You know, kind of like that run-down, hole-in-the-wall greasy-spoon restaurant has the Best Food! Looks aren’t everything. LOL! Love your show!

  • Tonya

    Julie’s cake looks homemade and I have had Banana Split Cake before and it is delicious. Leigh Anne, your cake looks like it came from a Designer!!

  • Amanda

    It’s a cute cake Leigh Ann but…really? Very Nice Julie!

  • Olivia

    Well, Leigh Ann, I will give you E for effort, but no way did you make it. Julie gets my vote.

  • Julie DeHarty

    LMIAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AS IF!!!!!!!! YOU SOOOOO DID NOT MAKE THAT CAKE!

  • Linda

    Sorry Leigh Ann, Julie’s was made from the heart. There’s nothing better than that!

  • Pat

    My daughter said that even if Leigh Ann had made the cake, which she did not, its really kind of ugly! Julie’s looks delicious:-)

  • annbel

    Leigh Ann must’ve made her cake in her really huge jungle of a bakery .. i mean kitchen. (lol) seriously, Leigh Ann -for shame!

  • Leigh Ann

    I worked really hard on that cake. You have no idea!!!!

    Leigh Ann

  • Melodie

    OMG! Leigh Ann that is great! I want the receipe! Julie, you should take notes from Leigh Ann. Your’s looks like a Dump Cake! LOLOL

  • charles goodwin

    well as for looks A is nice but home made is Always better.

  • Julie DeHarty

    Maybe if this was a CAKE EATING contest you’d win! No way Leigh Ann! Cake swindler!

  • charles goodwin

    A is pretty but Home made is way better always,,..

  • Donna

    Leigh Ann’s cake is very pretty, a little too pretty haha. Julie’s looks scrumptious, do we get a sample when this is over?

  • Robert

    Hmmm…why am I reminded of “Liar, Liar pants on fire!!!” ?

  • Kathleen

    Julie-your cake looks yummy!! No way Leigh Ann made that other one. :)

  • Sandra Talley

    Leigh Ann,cake bosses heart was in your cake,not yours!!!!!!!!LOL!!!!!!
    Julie great job,looks real yummy!!!!!

  • Alissa

    Please Leigh Ann buys everything, she doesn’t even know where the kitchen is in the house, if there is one!!

  • Debby

    Seriously?!?!?!?!? There’s no way Leigh Ann made that cake!

  • Amanda

    Okay Leigh Ann since we can google your cake I am pretty sure that means you did not make it! LOL

  • Leigh Ann

    I would give you all the recipe but it’s a family secret. Passed down from my grandma’s grandma.

    Leigh Ann

  • Julyia

    Leigh Ann, shame on you for using a famous cake-maker’s cake to enter into this contest…. we all know you don’t cook, don’t bake, and this cake did not even come from a Duncan Hines box either….. afraid I have to vote for Julie’s cake because it is real, and is believable. Love you both, love your show, and listen everyday and laugh at all the fun you two have…. xxx. p.s. I love banana split cakes, yummmm

  • Julie DeHarty

    By the looks of this cake you claim you made your relatives lived at the zoo.

  • Cyndi

    I think LeighAnn could bake a cake, just not finish it like that
    without help. I bake all the time and I would even make one like that. Sorry I will eat Julie’s

  • Linda

    Leigh Ann…I voted for Julie’s cake,cause it makes me hungry looking at it. I would vote for if this we’re a contest for the best looking fake cake…Good Try!!!!

blog comments powered by Disqus
Get Started Now App

Listen Live